Extension:OggHandler/Test matrix

From MediaWiki.org
Jump to: navigation, search

Please add your combination of browser and video player below.

General player bugs[edit | edit source]

Totem 
No seeking
VLC 
crashy, no built-in controls
Kaffeine 0.8.6 with xine
totally broken. Plays a few seconds and then stops, navigating away or closing will freeze the browser. Same in standalone player.
Kaffeine 0.8.6 with gstreamer
launches the standalone player, which works in full screen or minimal mode, not otherwise. Sometimes complains about the audio device already being open, for no apparent reason.
QuickTime/XiphQT 
sometimes the video stops and it needs pausing/resuming to get it going again

Firefox[edit | edit source]

Firefox 2.0.0.16 on Ubuntu 8.10:

  • Cortado: works
  • mplayerplug-in: works, but no seek bar

Firefox 3.0 on Ubuntu 8.04

  • Totem: works
  • VLC: works
  • Cortado: works

Firefox 3.1 on Ubuntu 8.04

  • video element: works with old OggHandler

Firefox 3.0 on Windows XP

  • Cortado: works
  • VLC: works
  • QuickTime: works

Firefox 3.1 on Windows XP

  • video element: works
  • Cortado: works
  • VLC: works
  • QuickTime: works

Firefox 3.0.5 on Windows XP

  • Cortado: mostly works, seeking is poor
  • VLC: crashy
  • Quicktime: mostly works, sometimes only audio works

Firefox 3.0.1 on Mac OS X 10.5 (Leopard)

  • Cortado: works in most cases

Konqueror[edit | edit source]

Konqueror 3.5.9 on Ubuntu 8.04

  • Kaffeine: kind of works (see bugs in general section)
  • KMPlayer 0.10.0c: works
  • VLC: totally broken, blacklisted
  • Cortado: totally broken, blacklisted

Opera[edit | edit source]

Opera 9.51 on Ubuntu 8.04

  • VLC: Broken, "Plug-in 12308 is not responding. It will be closed"
  • Cortado: Temperamental. Sometimes just shows a big grey box.
  • Kaffeine: kind of works (see bugs in general section)

Opera 9.51 on Windows XP

  • Cortado: works
  • VLC: works
  • QuickTime: works

Opera 9.52 July labs build on Windows XP:

  • video element: kind of works with innerHTML method, changing players leaves the sound going until you navigate away.
  • Cortado: works
  • VLC: Works
  • QuickTime: works


Opera 9.63 on MacOSX

  • Cortado: sound does not work correctly

Epiphany[edit | edit source]

Epiphany 2.22.2 on Ubuntu 8.04

  • Cortado: Mostly works, crash and "big grey box" observed by clicking links at inopportune times
  • VLC: mostly works, lockup observed when navigating away
  • Totem: works
  • Kaffeine works (except for general bugs)

Internet Explorer[edit | edit source]

IE 7 on Windows XP

  • Cortado: Temperamental. Sometimes fails to load the applet.
  • QuickTime: works
  • VLC: works

Safari[edit | edit source]

Safari 3.1.2 on Windows XP

  • Cortado: works
  • QuickTime: works
  • VLC: broken
  • video element: broken, plays a few seconds of video and then stops, audio continues. Pausing and resuming will show you a few frames more.

Safari 3.1.2 on MacOS X

  • Cortado: works
  • QuickTime: broken

Safari 4 beta on MacOS X

  • Cortado: video element: mostly works, progress bar problems have been reported