Topic on Talk:Talk pages project/New topic/Flow

Some bugs

6
Summary by PPelberg (WMF)

T272768: New Discussion Tool change tags

Patrik L. (talkcontribs)

Hello, I have found some bugs, maybe you know about some of them.

  • Please go here and try to add topic "Write 3 words". Selection is wrong, see screenshot.
  • Hover over a "Zrušit" button with a mouse cursor in Czech localisation and you will see "Zrušit Escape". Why?

And now, Czech Wikipedia is back at MW 1.36.0-wmf.26, so it does not work.

PPelberg (WMF) (talkcontribs)

Please go here and try to add topic "Write 3 words". Selection is wrong, see screenshot.

Can you share a bit more details, @Patriccck? When you say the selection is wrong, what steps did you take to make that selection? And what did you expect to happen after taking those steps?

Hover over a "Zrušit" button with a mouse cursor in Czech localisation and you will see "Zrušit Escape". Why?

Can you share what you did/did not expect to see when you hover over the Zrušit text?

For context, we implemented these tooltips as a way for people to learn the tools' keyboard shortcuts. More in T264913.

Patrik L. (talkcontribs)

When you say the selection is wrong, what steps did you take to make that selection? And what did you expect to happen after taking those steps?

@PPelberg (WMF) See this video, please. I am not sure, what it should select, bud certainly not "3 words */" because after replacement it will brake link to the section. Maybe it should select all the text in summary. Is it clear now?

Can you share what you did/did not expect to see when you hover over the Zrušit text?

I did not understand why is there "Zrušit Escape" (a combination of Czech and English) and now I understand that Escape is for a key. Here at mediawikiwiki discussions is Escape in the brackets – [Escape] – and it is better for understanding, I think.

Btw. could you please see this topic? I think is it important for some editors.

Tacsipacsi (talkcontribs)

I think it tries to select everything but the /* section link */ part. Maybe it can’t handle that the section link part is at the end? It works for me on Wikidata, where the default summary is /* section title */ new section.

Patrik L. (talkcontribs)

Why is an order of tags different in Reply tool and New discussion tool?

  • Reply tool tags order example: "Reply, Visual" – here is also a link
  • New discussion tags order example: "Source, New topic" – here is diffrent order and there is no link
PPelberg (WMF) (talkcontribs)

Great spot, @Patriccck – I'm glad you said something about this.

Here is the ticket where work on this issue will happen: T272768.