Team Practices Group/Mailing list analysis

The Team Practices Group (TPG) was dissolved in 2017.

This page is obsolete. It is being retained for archival purposes. It may document extensions or features that are obsolete and/or no longer supported. Do not rely on any information on this page.

Executive Summary[edit]

Transparency is a core value at the WMF. The question was raised as to how the TPG has been balancing its use of its internal private mailing list and the public teampractices list.

The results below show that the team currently has a strong tendency to use the private list, and there appear to be opportunities for increasing transparency.

Findings[edit]

As of 2015-06-10, the private list has 7 subscribers, and the public list has 120 (of which 64 have an @wikimedia.org address).

This analysis covers messages sent between April 1 and May 31, 2015

Public List[edit]

11 threads (46 total messages)

Who initiated the thread?

9 by TPGers (7 were by one individual)
2 by other WMF/WMDE folks

What topics were covered?

5 were of general “agile” interest
6 were about specific issues being faced at the WMF

Private List[edit]

73 threads (235 total messages)

41 threads were appropriately private
- 1 was a response to an individual asking for TPG help
- 15 referred to private documents (TPG or WMF)
- 18 were for TPG scheduling issues
- 7 were related to TPG-private WMF-private issues (e.g. retros and reorg)

32 threads could/should have been public
- 23 probably should have been public (about ⅓ might have needed edits)
  - 9 were on general Agile topics
  - 9 were related to team issues within the WMF
  - 5 were related to tools within the WMF (phab, megamatrix, flowcharts)
- 9 probably could have been public
  - 2 were on general Agile topics
  - 3 were related to team issues within the WMF (including TPG as a team)
  - 4 were related to tools within the WMF (phab, phragile, MPL, Q4 goals)