Anti-Harassment Tools/SecurePoll Improvements/Test Results/20 4 5000 8910242957/archive

From mediawiki.org
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Actual Tally: Secure Poll commit unknown[edit]

Elected[edit]

Election for 4 seats with 20 candidates. Total 5,000 votes.

  1. "4"
  2. "6"
  3. "13"
  4. "12"

Eliminated/Not elected[edit]

  • "8"
  • "2"
  • "14"
  • "17"
  • "15"
  • "3"
  • "11"
  • "5"
  • "19"
  • "7"
  • "10"
  • "16"
  • "20"
  • "9"
  • "18"
  • "1"

Rounds table[edit]

The following table describes the calculations that happened in order to achieve the result above. In each round of calculation, the candidate(s) who achieved more votes than the quota are declared elected. Their surplus votes above the quota are redistributed to the remaining candidates. If nobody achieves the quota, the lowest ranking candidate is eliminated and their votes are redistributed to the remaining candidates. To understand this better, please refer to this link.

Round Number Tally Result
1
  1. "13": 271
  2. "1": 264
  3. "9": 262
  4. "4": 262
  5. "20": 261
  6. "16": 260
  7. "6": 258
  8. "5": 258
  9. "18": 257
  10. "12": 255
  11. "19": 253
  12. "7": 252
  13. "3": 245
  14. "10": 243
  15. "15": 243
  16. "11": 243
  17. "17": 233
  18. "14": 232
  19. "2": 227
  20. "8": 221
Quota: 1,000.000001
2
  1. "13": 271
  2. "1": 264
  3. "9": 262
  4. "4": 262
  5. "20": 261
  6. "16": 260
  7. "6": 258
  8. "5": 258
  9. "18": 257
  10. "12": 255
  11. "19": 253
  12. "7": 252
  13. "3": 245
  14. "10": 243
  15. "15": 243
  16. "11": 243
  17. "17": 233
  18. "14": 232
  19. "2": 227
  20. "8": 221
Quota: 1,000.000001

Eliminated: "8"

3
  1. "1": 264 + 16.000000 = 280
  2. "13": 271 + 7.000000 = 278
  3. "18": 257 + 18.000000 = 275
  4. "4": 262 + 13.000000 = 275
  5. "9": 262 + 13.000000 = 275
  6. "6": 258 + 16.000000 = 274
  7. "12": 255 + 13.000000 = 268
  8. "5": 258 + 10.000000 = 268
  9. "16": 260 + 6.000000 = 266
  10. "20": 261 + 5.000000 = 266
  11. "7": 252 + 11.000000 = 263
  12. "19": 253 + 9.000000 = 262
  13. "3": 245 + 10.000000 = 255
  14. "15": 243 + 11.000000 = 254
  15. "10": 243 + 10.000000 = 253
  16. "11": 243 + 10.000000 = 253
  17. "14": 232 + 14.000000 = 246
  18. "17": 233 + 8.000000 = 241
  19. "2": 227 + 10.000000 = 237
Quota: 997.800001

Eliminated: "2" Transferring votes

4
  1. "18": 275 + 23.000000 = 298
  2. "13": 278 + 14.000000 = 292
  3. "1": 280 + 10.000000 = 290
  4. "6": 274 + 13.000000 = 287
  5. "9": 275 + 11.000000 = 286
  6. "4": 275 + 9.000000 = 284
  7. "12": 268 + 13.000000 = 281
  8. "16": 266 + 13.000000 = 279
  9. "19": 262 + 16.000000 = 278
  10. "5": 268 + 10.000000 = 278
  11. "7": 263 + 14.000000 = 277
  12. "20": 266 + 10.000000 = 276
  13. "3": 255 + 14.000000 = 269
  14. "10": 253 + 12.000000 = 265
  15. "11": 253 + 12.000000 = 265
  16. "15": 254 + 9.000000 = 263
  17. "14": 246 + 9.000000 = 255
  18. "17": 241 + 14.000000 = 255
Quota: 995.600001

Eliminated: "14", "17" Transferring votes

5
  1. "18": 298 + 33.000000 = 331
  2. "9": 286 + 37.000000 = 323
  3. "13": 292 + 29.000000 = 321
  4. "1": 290 + 28.000000 = 318
  5. "4": 284 + 33.000000 = 317
  6. "6": 287 + 29.000000 = 316
  7. "7": 277 + 39.000000 = 316
  8. "12": 281 + 34.000000 = 315
  9. "16": 279 + 35.000000 = 314
  10. "20": 276 + 36.000000 = 312
  11. "5": 278 + 26.000000 = 304
  12. "19": 278 + 24.000000 = 302
  13. "10": 265 + 31.000000 = 296
  14. "3": 269 + 23.000000 = 292
  15. "11": 265 + 25.000000 = 290
  16. "15": 263 + 22.000000 = 285
Quota: 990.400001

Eliminated: "15" Transferring votes

6
  1. "18": 331 + 17.000000 = 348
  2. "9": 323 + 22.000000 = 345
  3. "13": 321 + 18.000000 = 339
  4. "4": 317 + 20.000000 = 337
  5. "1": 318 + 16.000000 = 334
  6. "16": 314 + 20.000000 = 334
  7. "20": 312 + 22.000000 = 334
  8. "6": 316 + 16.000000 = 332
  9. "7": 316 + 13.000000 = 329
  10. "12": 315 + 13.000000 = 328
  11. "11": 290 + 32.000000 = 322
  12. "5": 304 + 14.000000 = 318
  13. "19": 302 + 16.000000 = 318
  14. "10": 296 + 14.000000 = 310
  15. "3": 292 + 16.000000 = 308
Quota: 987.200001

Eliminated: "3" Transferring votes

7
  1. "18": 348 + 19.000000 = 367
  2. "9": 345 + 22.000000 = 367
  3. "13": 339 + 28.000000 = 367
  4. "1": 334 + 25.000000 = 359
  5. "20": 334 + 24.000000 = 358
  6. "4": 337 + 21.000000 = 358
  7. "6": 332 + 22.000000 = 354
  8. "16": 334 + 16.000000 = 350
  9. "12": 328 + 17.000000 = 345
  10. "7": 329 + 12.000000 = 341
  11. "5": 318 + 18.000000 = 336
  12. "10": 310 + 25.000000 = 335
  13. "19": 318 + 17.000000 = 335
  14. "11": 322 + 11.000000 = 333
Quota: 981.000001

Eliminated: "11" Transferring votes

8
  1. "18": 367 + 27.000000 = 394
  2. "13": 367 + 25.000000 = 392
  3. "9": 367 + 22.000000 = 389
  4. "1": 359 + 27.000000 = 386
  5. "4": 358 + 24.000000 = 382
  6. "20": 358 + 20.000000 = 378
  7. "6": 354 + 23.000000 = 377
  8. "16": 350 + 21.000000 = 371
  9. "7": 341 + 28.000000 = 369
  10. "12": 345 + 19.000000 = 364
  11. "10": 335 + 24.000000 = 359
  12. "19": 335 + 24.000000 = 359
  13. "5": 336 + 19.000000 = 355
Quota: 975.000001

Eliminated: "5" Transferring votes

9
  1. "13": 392 + 28.000000 = 420
  2. "9": 389 + 29.000000 = 418
  3. "18": 394 + 20.000000 = 414
  4. "1": 386 + 23.000000 = 409
  5. "6": 377 + 32.000000 = 409
  6. "4": 382 + 26.000000 = 408
  7. "16": 371 + 29.000000 = 400
  8. "7": 369 + 30.000000 = 399
  9. "20": 378 + 19.000000 = 397
  10. "10": 359 + 37.000000 = 396
  11. "12": 364 + 32.000000 = 396
  12. "19": 359 + 28.000000 = 387
Quota: 970.600001

Eliminated: "19" Transferring votes

10
  1. "9": 418 + 40.000000 = 458
  2. "6": 409 + 45.000000 = 454
  3. "13": 420 + 32.000000 = 452
  4. "18": 414 + 30.000000 = 444
  5. "1": 409 + 34.000000 = 443
  6. "4": 408 + 31.000000 = 439
  7. "20": 397 + 32.000000 = 429
  8. "16": 400 + 24.000000 = 424
  9. "10": 396 + 27.000000 = 423
  10. "12": 396 + 27.000000 = 423
  11. "7": 399 + 22.000000 = 421
Quota: 962.000001

Eliminated: "7" Transferring votes

11
  1. "6": 454 + 43.000000 = 497
  2. "9": 458 + 30.000000 = 488
  3. "18": 444 + 42.000000 = 486
  4. "13": 452 + 29.000000 = 481
  5. "4": 439 + 37.000000 = 476
  6. "1": 443 + 32.000000 = 475
  7. "12": 423 + 51.000000 = 474
  8. "16": 424 + 45.000000 = 469
  9. "20": 429 + 38.000000 = 467
  10. "10": 423 + 38.000000 = 461
Quota: 954.800001

Eliminated: "10" Transferring votes

12
  1. "6": 497 + 51.000000 = 548
  2. "18": 486 + 48.000000 = 534
  3. "13": 481 + 46.000000 = 527
  4. "1": 475 + 50.000000 = 525
  5. "9": 488 + 36.000000 = 524
  6. "12": 474 + 50.000000 = 524
  7. "4": 476 + 45.000000 = 521
  8. "16": 469 + 41.000000 = 510
  9. "20": 467 + 43.000000 = 510
Quota: 944.600001

Eliminated: "16", "20" Transferring votes

13
  1. "6": 548 + 148.000000 = 696
  2. "13": 527 + 132.000000 = 659
  3. "1": 525 + 131.000000 = 656
  4. "12": 524 + 130.000000 = 654
  5. "18": 534 + 118.000000 = 652
  6. "4": 521 + 122.000000 = 643
  7. "9": 524 + 113.000000 = 637
Quota: 919.400001

Eliminated: "9" Transferring votes

14
  1. "6": 696 + 82.000000 = 778
  2. "4": 643 + 113.000000 = 756
  3. "1": 656 + 98.000000 = 754
  4. "12": 654 + 87.000000 = 741
  5. "13": 659 + 81.000000 = 740
  6. "18": 652 + 87.000000 = 739
Quota: 901.600001

Eliminated: "18" Transferring votes

15
  1. "6": 778 + 122.000000 = 900
  2. "13": 740 + 144.000000 = 884
  3. "4": 756 + 127.000000 = 883
  4. "12": 741 + 123.000000 = 864
  5. "1": 754 + 107.000000 = 861
Quota: 878.400001

Elected: "4", "6", "13" Transferring votes

16
  1. "4": 883 + 0.981724 = 883.981724 (keep factor: 0.994790)
  2. "13": 884 - 0.555922 = 883.444078 (keep factor: 0.993665)
  3. "6": 900 - 19.471504 = 880.528496 (keep factor: 0.976000)
  4. "12": 864 + 6.528285 = 870.528285
  5. "1": 861 + 6.026859 = 867.026859
Quota: 877.101889

Transferring votes

17
  1. "6": 880.528496 - 0.688724 = 879.839772 (keep factor: 0.972202)
  2. "13": 883.444078 - 4.427969 = 879.016109 (keep factor: 0.986532)
  3. "4": 883.981724 - 5.017901 = 878.963823 (keep factor: 0.987048)
  4. "12": 870.528285 + 3.435149 = 873.963434
  5. "1": 867.026859 + 3.323575 = 870.350434
Quota: 876.426715

Transferring votes

18
  1. "4": 878.963823 - 1.358186 = 877.605637 (keep factor: 0.984199)
  2. "13": 879.016109 - 1.470569 = 877.545540 (keep factor: 0.983626)
  3. "6": 879.839772 - 2.354857 = 877.484915 (keep factor: 0.968431)
  4. "12": 873.963434 + 1.764730 = 875.728164
  5. "1": 870.350434 + 1.674791 = 872.025225
Quota: 876.077897

Transferring votes

19
  1. "6": 877.484915 - 0.789977 = 876.694938 (keep factor: 0.966878)
  2. "12": 875.728164 + 0.910865 = 876.639029
  3. "4": 877.605637 - 0.970832 = 876.634805 (keep factor: 0.982486)
  4. "13": 877.545540 - 0.919776 = 876.625764 (keep factor: 0.981981)
  5. "1": 872.025225 + 0.871560 = 872.896785
Quota: 875.898265

Elected: "12" Transferring votes

(Results from 04:00, 1 September 2021)

Actual commit 552e3bcc1e177a54f04c7fb641bceef87d1b8df8[edit]

Output from SecurePoll: https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/P16897