Thread:Talk:Article feedback/Please exempt redirects and short articles/reply (7)


 * I suggest that articles shorter than some character limit should simply be exempt from this rating system. I'm thinking that 64 characters should be non-controversial, while 1024 might be too much.

It should be noted, though, that this would need to be configurable on each wiki, and it should probably use some other measure instead of the size of the wikitext in bytes, since e.g. on Wikisources a page can have just a few characters and still be a long page (since most pages are transcluded from "Page:" namespace by the Extension:Proofread Page). Maybe it would be better to consider the size of the expanded wikitext of the page.