Thread:Talk:Article feedback/AFT Calls to action: review and future directions/reply

Why are there no completion rates for the Join CTA?

Given (1) the current positioning of the AFT at the bottom of the page, (2) the fact that it's not actually loaded until users scroll to the bottom of the page and (3) the fact that we know that rating conversions (i.e. the number of people rating an article after reading it) decay very rapidly with the page length, it's highly unlikely that rating may be distracting people from editing the article (people interested in editing would have done so using the main edit tab or section edit links) even if we currently do not have data to test this hypothesis. If this hypothesis holds, though, we can reasonably assume that edits produced via the Edit CTA, however small in volume, are additional to regular edits.

Emphasis mine.

Why do you think that is reasonable? I would chose another word to describe the quality of that assumption.

This could be done by sending WikiLove to the top 5 contributors of the article... Are you manually going to identify the top 5 contributors to every article? Its impossible to identify the top 5 contributors to an article with software.