Thread:Talk:Article feedback/Three requests for Fabrice (new project lead)/reply (7)

WhatamIdoing makes some very reasonable points that there are distinct benefits in encouraging editors to use the AFT as well, not just readers.

In fact, we are considering a way to sort the feedback page for each article so that editor comments could be listed first, so that we can hear from these more experienced and committed users as well, above and beyond reader comments.

And if we follow Jorm's idea of using this tool to create a "work list", it would become even more important to have editorial participation.

Lastly, we want to make sure that we create more opportunities for readers and editors to collaborate, a goal which could be harmed by segregating these two user groups. We hope this tool can be valuable for everyone!

But we will strive to make it more compact, to address editor concerns. And it is already possible for an editor to disable that function if they do not want it.

Thanks for this great discussion, which is truly helpful! You are asking the right questions and it will make our work a lot easier as a result.