Thread:Talk:Article feedback/Legend for each rating (1-5 stars)/reply (6)

For best result they should mention the category being rated:


 * 1) Not X
 * 2) Somewhat not X
 * 3) Neither X nor not X
 * 4) Somewhat X
 * X

Where X is any of "trustworthy", "objective", "complete" or "well-written"--BTW can anyone point me at the discussion where was decided on picking these particular four categories? I'd love to see some rationale for it.

And of course the descriptions should be reworded a littlebit because "Somewhat not well-written" sounds like crap :-P

The legend should appear directly below the stars, and change as the user changes the star-rating.

Implementing this is very important in order to ensure the most consistency amongst ratings.