Thread:Talk:Article feedback/Irrelevant/reply (11)

I'll expand on your point number 4). A tool that does not provide sufficient data for editors is utterly useless.

And I didn't suggest that any one criticism should warrant vetoing the project. That's your defence to the various sweeping criticisms and it's irrelevant. What I am suggesting is that there is so much conceptual criticism and so little response of a worthwhile nature that the project seems like it's dead already but simply won't lie down.