Thread:Talk:Requests for comment/Localisation format/A quite popular case.../reply (8)

On your points:


 * Using .i18n.php directly for translation
 * The main workflow for translators is translatewiki.net, where the English original (and qqq message) are clearly shown alongside the input box – I don't know if many people are manually paging through the i18n.php file for the English original. However, I agree that wanting to know how a message was translated into a related language (e.g. French and Spanish, or German and Swiss German) for consistency is probably a useful artefact we might want to suggest to TWN as a translation tool?


 * Multiple files touched in one git commit
 * I see this as a feature, not a bug – as someone who manually reviews every single VisualEditor git commit from the localisation update, it's now much much easier for me to see at a glance what languages got new messages or updated messages, and particularly when a language is newly added.


 * Removing a message across several files
 * The official guidance on this is that only the -en message should be removed by the developers, and the system will remove the non-en messages, so I don't think this is a problem here.