Thread:Talk:Article feedback/Gaming the system, is there a way to have both useful ratings and conversion of readers to editors?/reply (3)

One of my questions earlier on at this talkpage was about the RFP for the "extended" article feedback tool: Talk:Article_feedback. Does this mean Fabrice is the person who has been given the project?

With regards to the presentation, linked above, I really like the idea of a new "reviews" tab in the skin especially if it will enable all the functionality identified in the "extended AFT" wireframes and in the presentation :-) I may have overlooked it, but is there any intention of integrating the AFT with the existing Article Rating system in use on talkpages (the FA, GA, B, C, Start, Stub system), or will it be kept separate? I think it would be a shame to have two completely independent ratings systems as that would merely perpetuate what we currently have now - one rating system for readers (that is scorned by users) and one rating system for users (that is unknown to readers). Wittylama 05:19, 13 October 2011 (UTC)