Talk:Flow Portal/MVP

Sounds promising
I think this is a great way to pilot Flow, and potentially a boon for WikiProjects (which are dear to my heart). A couple of questions/suggestions/crazy ideas:
 * will Flow play nicely with archiving bots, like MiszaBot?
 * Thanks for reminding me that I hadn't covered archiving (yet) :) I've added a note about that and search in the doc. The answer to your specific question is that manual or bot archiving in the current wiki way may not make sense with a discussion feature that has infinite scroll capability – we could always show the most recent discussions on top and lazy-load older ones below, making them accessible via scrolling. That + a robust search feature may be far more useful than creating static, arbitrarily defined archives via a bot. If I'm looking for a particular discussion, being able to search for all discussions that match certain keywords, users, or date ranges would be far more useful than a list of archived discussions 1-23,234.


 * this is way out of scope for MVP, but have you considered adding an optional "resolved" button for threads? A lot of project_talk posts are more like bug tickets than conversations.
 * I actually did consider that feature for the MVP! It would obviously be super useful. What stopped me was the fact that we have two similar and somewhat overlapping feature ideas for this kind of workflow: a "resolved" button, which could be on a per-comment basis, and a "closed" button, which could collapse the entire closed topic and all associated comments and replace it with a brief summary (e.g., "SNOW close of this RfC to change n-dashes to m-dashes in Nickelback articles"). I think it might be good to let users play with the prototype and decide which of these things they want most for WikiProject discussions (whether it's one or both).


 * If you're looking for projects to test this out on, I would be happy to suggest coordinators to reach out to.
 * Yes! Suggestions welcome :)

Apologies if any of this is covered elsewhere in the Flow doc. Jmorgan (WMF) (talk) 23:42, 20 August 2013 (UTC)


 * Thanks for the feedback, J-mo! In-line replies to your queries above ^ Maryana (WMF) (talk) 00:36, 21 August 2013 (UTC)