MobileFrontend/Feedback

Here is the main page for feedback on the mobile site.

UI

 * The search box seems to be missing. Was that intentional? If not, let's put it back in.
 * Let's poll people on this. I see pros/cons to it. Tfinc (talk) 00:35, 21 March 2012 (UTC)


 * In the footer, I know there were some lingering issues regarding the text about CC and registered trademark. Could we shorten that text to: "Wikipedia is a registered trademark of the Wikimedia Foundation, Inc., a non-profit organization. Terms of Use". We can keep the Contact Us link there for now, but that will go away when we have the new Contact page ready.


 * I think you had a question about how to programmatically retrieve that text from the site - is that still a question?


 * On the bottom line, could you make the text larger, and shorten each to a single word? So:
 * Contact  Privacy   About   Disclaimers


 * Finally, the Feedback page for this beta and subsequent ones is here:
 * https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/MobileFrontend/Feedback
 * So I assume we should direct comments from the Contact form to this page.

--Pchang (talk) 00:27, 21 March 2012 (UTC)


 * Were dismissing the keyboard right after we enter full screen mode but before the user can type anything. MAJOR ANNOYANCE
 * Lets consider changing "Type your search here" to "Tap to search" .. Its simpler, shorter, and more correct as we see touch devices take over. This will also make it not scroll of the screen if a user uses a larger font.
 * Find a page that takes a long time to load and tap search while its still loading. After it finishes loading try to type out the rest of your search. It wont work
 * Load this pl artice tap ref. Expand the 'Historia' section and tap [3] ref. You'll see that the X overlaps the text
 * If we can make the reference follow a user scrolling then lets do it. Having it jump is annoying
 * Tapping on [citation needed] shows a pop up that says the same thing. Perhaps we should say 'Add one by visiting our desktop site'
 * This was my thought... think of it as a placeholder for some cool mobile feature to allow people to add one Jdlrobson (talk)
 * Arabic Wikipedia footer text is smashed together and is only in english
 * It says 'by SA 3.0more information'
 * The CC logo is also on the far left while the page text is on the far right
 * Collapsing content it really jittery. It seems to happen in two steps rather then one making it visually distracting.
 * A small subset of pages don't fit neatly into the beta window. For instance on en wiki "Boston Red Sox" works great for default but fails in beta mode
 * Does anyone actually use "Jump back a section" ? ... If not lets ditch it

Opera

 * Opera Mini on Android doesn't show the "Type your search here" text
 * Full screen search never shows suggestions
 * Full screen search shows awkward rectangular box when typing in text

Firefox Mobile

 * Tapping a reference links scrolls you to the bottom of the page and then does nothing
 * Tapping full screen search zoom in too far. So far you can't see the '<'

Tfinc (talk) 00:39, 21 March 2012 (UTC)

From James Alexander:


 * the search location 'feels' a bit odd because it's basically right under my normal search box (in the right hand corner of the browser)


 * I personally really like the footer, much cleaner. Obviously I'd check with legal to make sure they're happy there (I assume so I don't think it's an issue). The other question would be that 1. The more information is right next to the cc-by logo and makes me think 'More information about the license' and not necessarily the other 4 links there. especially since the big chunk of text that comes up IS about the license, I almost didn't notice the other links you also have contact us twice


 * Love the references, love love love


 * the jump back a section question is interesting... I tend to get annoyed about scrolling up a ton to get to something but I'm not sure I'm trained to use a link like that... so not sure I would (at least yet).