Thread:Talk:New Page Patrol Zoom Interface/Delayed action tags/reply (11)

I'm not convinced this is a wording issue, politely interrupting someone to tell them you have a problem with their new article is still going to be perceived as an unwelcome interruption and a rejection of someone's work.

Clearly we have two very different interpretations of newbie behaviour. Some people it important to template them during their first edit session, others including myself think it important not to. A bit of research might establish whether either view is correct, or whether some combination would be better. For example how cool would it be if someone was trying to save a page of Arabic text on the English language wikipedia and the the system said to them in Arabic and English "This is the English language Wikipedia and that page seems to mostly be in Arabic. Would you rather add it it to the Arabic Wikipedia? Yes/No. And if they tick yes it moves them and their page to the Arabic Wikipedia.