Thread:Talk:Article feedback/Justin Bieber article not complete?/reply (4)

The easiest solution is to not ask for ratings but instead asking to comment on the talkpage.

If, for example, someone gives the Bieber article 5 stars in every category, it means "OMG Justin Bieber is so cute I love him!". If that person wrote that in English on the talkpage then we would be able to understand the reason why that person rated that article in that way.

The same principle applies to 1 star ratings in every category, they basically mean "Fuck Bieber".

We should not ask for ratings, we should ask why people rate an article the way they do.

We shouldn't invent a problem (not being able to determine the intentions of the person who gave the feedback), then try adjust algorithms so the effect is less extreme.