Thread:Talk:Article feedback/Is this a positive or a negative?/reply (8)

The problem is that we want to give text input, not a 1-5 star rating. This feedback should, of course, be visible to the public. We already have a place where anyone can place feedback on an article. It is called a talkpage.

But the decision to NOT move this tool to the talkpage and develop it into something useful while it is there has already been made.

I think this is a very unfortunate decision, I think I realize what the implications are and I think it would be a great idea to move the AFT to the talkpages and display the feedback there, especially in this stage of its development.

As History2007 points out it might take multiple years for the AFT to achieve its potentially "great results", and some people are even sceptical about the greatness of those results.

The AFT is currently still shown to people who create a new stub, I hope the new deployment comes soon so that problem will be fixed.