Thread:Talk:Requests for comment/Page protection as a component/Tainted?/reply

I think the RFC should be scoped down to reflect the summary that Adam himself made of it on IRC: 21:11:47 To summarize the [page] protection as a component thing, I noticed that there's a lot of security logic mixed in among classes which have other responsibilities. Moving to extension, reinventing FlaggedRevs, ACL etc. are each an entirely different and huge topic which is completely unexplained in the current text; mixing them all is certain to block any progress forever.