VisualEditor/Planning and testing

This is a directory of pages related to the planning and testing process of the VisualEditor extension. Some pages document deprecated aspects of the software, and are kept for historical purposes.

Planning

 * "Forward-look" documents:
 * 2012-13 Q1
 * 2012-13 Q2
 * 2012-13 Q3


 * Agendas, meeting agendas for the development team
 * Roadmap, plan for VisualEditor as of August 21, 2012
 * Phase 2, description of the second phase of the VisualEditor development
 * Todo list
 * Todo later list, list of tasks de-scoped for the June 2013 release of the VisualEditor
 * FAQs from the June 2012 release
 * Undo and redo, planning for these functions (historical)

Testing

 * Test, a general test page
 * Template test, a test page for templates
 * References test, a test page for references
 * Typing, testing for languages requiring input methods
 * Indic, testing for Indic language characters
 * Right-to-left, testing for languages using right-to-left character placement
 * Testing Non-Latin Characters Input and Behavior, for non-Latin characters

JavaScript tests
The VisualEditor JavaScript QUnit tests are in test subdirectories of some modules. They need to run in a browser. You can visit Special:JavaScriptTest/qunit to run all tests (which will take a long time to complete in your browser), or choose an individual module from the dropdown. Append ?filter=ve to the URL to run all modules matching "ve" which will run all VisualEditor tests plus some others ( try it on test2wiki). You can also run VisualEditor's QUnit tests from the commandline using the Grunt JavaScript task runner, which will start up a PhantomJS headless browser to run them.

Grunt can also run the JSHint code checker. See Gruntfile.js.

Browser tests
 is a set of browser tests that perform some VE actions.

You can run these tests yourself by installing the necessary software, see Quality Assurance/Browser testing/Running and writing tests; the easiest setup is to run a MediaWiki-Vagrant virtual machine and enable the roles  and.

https://github.com/inez/VE-tests/ has some additional browser tests developed in a different framework (Selenium), they test basics such as typing, breaking a paragraph into two paragraphs, bold, list, etc.

Continuous integration tests
When developers submit changes to VisualEditor, and later when other developers approve ("+2") them in gerrit, Jenkins runs a subset of VE tests: jshint, PHPcs, qunit tests.
 * last failed lint check

WMF QA regularly runs browser tests in multiple browser at https://wmf.ci.cloudbees.com, visiting pages on wikis, including beta labs (which is running master) and test2wiki (which is running the most current wmf branch). Click the [r-ve] tab to see all VisualEditor runs.

Dirty diff checking
There is a bot that runs VisualEditor, picks a random article, saves it, and checks for diffs arising from round-trip editing and Parsoid parsing. Source here, output here. Any dirty diff is a bug in either VisualEditor or Parsoid, even normalizations with no visible change (whitespace, quoting arguments)
 * TODO should improve dirtydiffbot to indicated whether it triggered VE's  [ message], issue filed on github

Other

 * Fail, (historical)