Help:Content translation/Translating/Initial machine translation

When adding a new paragraph to the translation you can start from scratch or use an automatic translation as a starting point. When available, machine translation is used by default as an initial translation. The different options, the details about their availability, and the considerations when using machine translation are described below.

Options for the initial translation
The "initial translation" options in the tools column allow you to decide the initial content to use as a starting point for each paragraph. The options available are the following:


 * Use a machine translation service. This allows you to start with an automatically translated version of the original paragraph. The number and name of these options will vary.  Options such as "Use Apertium" or "Use Yandex" will be available depending on the supported languages for these services (more on this on the next section).


 * Copy original content. The original paragraph will be copied over into the translation. Although content will remain in the original language, some elements are adapted to the target wiki.  for example, links will point to the corresponding article in the target language, and templates will be converted into the equivalent ones.  Translators still have to rewrite the content completely, but the adapted elements may be easier to reuse.


 * Start with an empty paragraph. Starting with an empty paragraph can be useful in cases where the alternative content requires more work than just typing it.

You can quickly switch between the different approaches independently on each paragraph, since each one may work best on different kinds of content. Switching between the different approaches preserves the changes you made on the paragraph. In this way, you can try a different approach even if you started editing the original one without the fear to lose your changes if you finally decide to go back to the original approach. Two additional options are relevant in this context:


 * The reset translation option is available when you made modifications to the initial content provided. It allows you to restore the initial content by discarding the changes you made.


 * The mark as default option is available when you select an approach for a paragraph that is not the default. It allows you to set the default approach for the next paragraphs that are added to the translation.  This can be very convenient if you found that a particular translation service works generally better than the default one.

Machine translation availability
Content translation integrates several translation services, and each service supports a different set of languages. The services supported are listed below with a link to the list of languages they support:


 *  ( languages supported )
 * OpusMT ( languages supported )
 *  ( languages supported )
 *  ( languages supported )
 *  ( languages supported )
 *  ( languages supported )
 * Elia(formerly known as Matxin) (languages supported)

The lists of languages above point to the configuration code to make sure that the information is in sync with the way the tool currently works. The lists show the language code for the source language at the initial indentation level and the codes of all the supported target languages below it.

You can also check the available services for a specific language pair using our APIs. In this example for the Spanish-Catalan pair, you can see that Apertium is the default service (first in the list) among the other services available.

Languages are enabled gradually, based on the observed results and community feedback. It is possible that machine translation for some languages has not been enabled yet, even if they are supported by the underlying services.

Improving existing translation services
When you publish a translation with Content Translation you are helping translation services improve. All the corrections you make to the initial machine translations are 1>Special:MyLanguage/Content translation/Published translations|exposed through an API and data dumps and can be potentially used to improve existing services. In addition to that, some of the translation services listed above provide specific ways you can contribute to their projects.

OpusMT
[http://opus.nlpl.eu/ OpusMT] is an open source neural machine translation system that is trained with multilingual documents freely licensed and available online. This open corpus is used to train the translation system, and expanding the corpus will lead to better translations. The contents generated by using Content Translation are [http://opus.nlpl.eu/wikimedia.php integrated automatically in the corpus], but you can contribute to expand the corpus further:


 * Propose new sources to be integrated in the open corpus. You can contact [https://researchportal.helsinki.fi/en/persons/j%C3%B6rg-tiedemann Jörg Tiedemann] to propose a new data source to expand the corpus.


 * [https://opus-repository.ling.helsinki.fi Submit documents directly] (still a preliminary prototype). You can upload translated documents in various formats including translated webpages to be incorporated to the corpus.
 * Try language models locally with [https://github.com/Helsinki-NLP/OPUS-CAT OPUS-CAT] (available for Windows)

OpusMT is based on [https://marian-nmt.github.io/ MarianNMT] which is also an open source project. People with technical knowledge and interested in machine learning can also contribute to improve it.

Apertium
[https://www.apertium.org/ Apertium] is an open source rule-based translation system. You can contribute to the project by encoding the language rules of your language. This process requires both linguistic and advanced technical knowledge, but you can get support from the Apertium team to expand the translation support for a new language pair.

Google Translate
Google Translate is not an open source project, but there are still ways for users to contribute back:


 * Join [https://translate.google.com/community</> the Google Translate Community] to provide translations that help train their system.


 * [<tvar|url>https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/new?component=187144&template=1161182</> Report bugs] when the translation system shows unexpected behavior when dealing with certain elements such as [<tvar|url2>https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/119256504</> spacing], numerals or [<tvar|url3>https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/149630958</> end of sentence marks] ([<tvar|url4>https://issuetracker.google.com/issues?q=componentid:187144%20status:open</> view full list]).

Expanding language support with new translation services
Content translation has been designed as an extensible platform. So it is possible to 1>Special:MyLanguage/Content translation/Machine Translation/MT Clients</>|develop new clients to integrate additional translation services. Some considerations about the way translation services are integrated:


 * Machine translations and the user corrections made are published as part of 1>Special:MyLanguage/Content translation/Published translations</>|the data on published translations, which can provide a useful resource to create or improve your translation service.


 * External services integrated only receive publicly available wiki content, and return a translated version of such content that is compatible with the licenses used in the wiki. No personal information is shared with the translation services.

Feedback on the support provided for each language is very useful. Please, let us know if you are missing support for some language, or whether higher quality options are available for it. You can provide such feedback 1>Talk:Content translation</>|on the project talk page or 2>phab:T86700</>|in this ticket.

Considerations on machine translation
Machine translation is far from perfect when intended as a final outcome. However, many users find it very useful as a starting point. Please make sure to review the content from these different perspectives:


 * Make sure the original meaning is preserved.


 * Check that there is no information missing, especially for elements such as links, references and templates that include information that is not always visible on the surface.


 * Read the translated content to make sure it reads naturally as an independent page.

Limitations with complex elements
In some cases the content may not appear in the translation as expected:


 * Some of the services supported only work with plain text. This means that formatting and rich content elements such as links and citations from the original article are lost in the translation, and Content translation needs to guess where those belong in the translated text.  Re-adding those elements is not always perfect and some elements may be in the wrong position or applied to the wrong part of the text.


 * Complex elements such as references or templates may use a different structure in each language, which makes it hard to transfer the content from one language into the other. Make sure to review the contents inside those elements to make sure there is no important information missing.

Enforcing the review of machine translation
Several automatic mechanisms exist to 1>Special:MyLanguage/Help:Content translation/Translating/Translation quality</>|enforce the review of the initial contents. In this way, the tool makes sure that the initial automatic translation is reviewed enough before the contents get published.