Thread:Talk:Article feedback/Please stop/reply (27)

If its too cluttered: please make your own suggestion with paint or photoshop.

We can use toggle links, we can add a link called "rate this page" in the sidebar, if we ask for one rating per page instead of 4 we can put 5 stars in the sidebar, we can use a lightbox effect, there are many options and only popups is explicitly disallowed. I do not know why they chose to put this huge box on lots of articles, it is far from necessary, and some of the other possibilities seem much more userfriendly.

Unfortunately the article feedback tool will not improve things. I think it wastes a lot of time devs could spend on things that actually matter.

Afaik there is no consensus to implement the article feedback boxes, and I have yet to see consensus for the important designchoices (but I am still reading).