Help:Lua/Lua best practice

As any "best practice", this Lua best practice is heavily influenced by any individual contributors impression of what should be good practice. Use whatever you believe is important on your specific project, but do also know that these rules have been found to work!

The examples in the following are for Lua, but it should be easy to reformulate for JavaScript, PHP, and Python. The reason for giving examples for Lua is that modules for this language are used a lot, often by non-programmers that does not see the consequence of their choices.

As a general advice it can be a great help to at least import the content into a proper programming environment and check it there for obvious flaws and errors. Several free options exist, among them Eclipse, TextMate, and Visual Studio Code just to mention a few.

Names

 * Descriptive names
 * Chose descriptive names, avoid overly generic names like  unless your code is truly generic. Don't repeat a description on several levels, like a method name set to the same as a class name, unless the method in fact return a class of that type. Think colorful words.


 * Short names
 * Cryptic short names should be avoided. Spell out the names, but stay concise. Don't use, say instead   or  . Often you can reformulate the sort names and still keep them short, like   and  . Use a plural name for tables holding several values for example.


 * Iterator names
 * Iterators usually have short names in Lua, and the names carry special meaning. This can create problems if several nested loops shall use the same names. A common solution is to prefix or suffix an additional part to the name, usually from the plural form used by the collection, or to use a singular form of the name of the collection.

Formatting

 * Limit line length
 * Lines should be limited to a reasonable length, typically 80 characters. The reason is that long lines are hard to read, but more import, long lines tend to contain several intermingled concepts and editing them will tend to create new bugs.


 * Indentation
 * Programmers have opinions on how to do indentation. Whatever opinion you have, do remember that crowdsourced projects should adhere to some common standards. Because the on-line editor do indentation in specific ways you should set your programming environment to act the same way.

Documentation

 * Interface documentation
 * The interface is the exposed functions from the module, that is the functions you can invoke from the parser function. As a minimum document whatever arguments the interface function takes, and whatever value it return. Only a single value is used from whatever the function returns. Remember to document if and how the metafunction  will transform the value.

Comments

 * Why-form of comments
 * Comments are not for you who code some algorithm, they are for the one who reads your code. In the code path there should be answers to the how-questions, and in the comments there should be answers to the why-questions. Do not fall in the trap of replicating what you do in the code path in the comments!


 * Refactor on comments
 * When the code has become to complex, it is common to start explaining the code for yourself. If you need your own comments, then something has gotten to involved and you should refactor the code.

Code

 * Use patterns
 * A lot of work has gone into identifying common software design patterns, and developing good general solutions to those patterns. If you suspect you are attempting to do something that has a common pattern then do a search and check out how to implement the pattern. Still, know that patterns for languages with closures can be very different from those without closures.


 * Complexity
 * There are usually several execute paths through a given code, and this makes the code difficult to understand. The more code paths the more difficult the code become. This can be measured as cyclomatic complexity, and is a count of paths by counting branch points.


 * Return early
 * Return as soon as you can, especially if something fails. Usually programmers are told to stick with a single return point, but due to the language constructs in Lua this seems to create involved code. It is thus better to return early.
 * {| class="wikitable mw-collapsible mw-collapsed"

!colspan="2"|Example !Good !Bad
 * - valign="top"
 * }
 * Avoid else
 * All conditionals can be written so en explicit else-clause goes away. All of them. But sometimes the else-clause makes the code easier to read or make double set of if-clauses go away. In those cases it is acceptable to keep the, otherwise it should be removed. Always be suspicious about else-clauses.
 * Avoid else
 * All conditionals can be written so en explicit else-clause goes away. All of them. But sometimes the else-clause makes the code easier to read or make double set of if-clauses go away. In those cases it is acceptable to keep the, otherwise it should be removed. Always be suspicious about else-clauses.


 * Truthy first
 * Usually you are free to order the order of then- and else-clauses as you see fit, and then you should order them so the if-clause has a positive test. This makes the code easier to read. If you can avoid the else-clause that is although more important.
 * {| class="wikitable mw-collapsible mw-collapsed"

!colspan="2"|Example !Good !Bad
 * - valign="top"
 * }
 * Provide defaults
 * In languages with an  operator like in Lua it is very easy to provide defaults. This is nice as some common constructs fails badly if given an uninitialized value. This happen for example when a table is unitialized and the code tries to index the nil value.
 * {| class="wikitable mw-collapsible mw-collapsed"
 * In languages with an  operator like in Lua it is very easy to provide defaults. This is nice as some common constructs fails badly if given an uninitialized value. This happen for example when a table is unitialized and the code tries to index the nil value.
 * {| class="wikitable mw-collapsible mw-collapsed"

!colspan="2"|Example !Good !Bad
 * - valign="top"
 * }
 * Interrogated first
 * Usually the interrogated value goes first in a logical expression, as this is is more natural to read and thus less error prone. The inverted form is sometimes called the Yoda form. Sometimes (but rarely) the natural form does not work as expected, and the code terminates. This can be because Lua fails figure out a proper tail recursive form of the expression, and then the stack overflows.
 * {| class="wikitable mw-collapsible mw-collapsed"
 * Usually the interrogated value goes first in a logical expression, as this is is more natural to read and thus less error prone. The inverted form is sometimes called the Yoda form. Sometimes (but rarely) the natural form does not work as expected, and the code terminates. This can be because Lua fails figure out a proper tail recursive form of the expression, and then the stack overflows.
 * {| class="wikitable mw-collapsible mw-collapsed"

!colspan="2"|Example !Good !Bad
 * - valign="top"
 * }
 * Binary conditional
 * Lua does not have an binary conditional operator, but you can do the same anyhow with an . What goes on is although a little mysterious to newcomers to Lua. The   and   pass on truthy values, and thus they can be part of other expressions than just logical ones.
 * {| class="wikitable mw-collapsible mw-collapsed"
 * Lua does not have an binary conditional operator, but you can do the same anyhow with an . What goes on is although a little mysterious to newcomers to Lua. The   and   pass on truthy values, and thus they can be part of other expressions than just logical ones.
 * {| class="wikitable mw-collapsible mw-collapsed"

!colspan="2"|Example !Good !Bad
 * - valign="top"
 * }
 * Ternary conditional
 * Lua does not have an ternary conditional operator, but you can do the same anyhow with an  and an  . What goes on is although a little mysterious to newcomers to Lua. The   and   pass on truthy values, and thus they can be part of other expressions than just logical ones.
 * {| class="wikitable mw-collapsible mw-collapsed"
 * Lua does not have an ternary conditional operator, but you can do the same anyhow with an  and an  . What goes on is although a little mysterious to newcomers to Lua. The   and   pass on truthy values, and thus they can be part of other expressions than just logical ones.
 * {| class="wikitable mw-collapsible mw-collapsed"

!colspan="2"|Example !Good !Bad
 * - valign="top"
 * }
 * Avoid repeat until
 * The loop construct  delays the test until after the loop. This is error prone and should be avoided. The only times this is acceptable is when the test itself is costly compared to the executed block, or avoiding the repeat-clause would imply additional cleanup or finalize code.
 * Avoid repeat until
 * The loop construct  delays the test until after the loop. This is error prone and should be avoided. The only times this is acceptable is when the test itself is costly compared to the executed block, or avoiding the repeat-clause would imply additional cleanup or finalize code.

Reading

 * Kerievsky, Joshua; Refactoring to Patterns
 * Boswell, Dustin; Foucher, Trevor; The Art of Readable Code