Anti-Harassment Tools/SecurePoll Improvements/Test Results/7 6 566 1185838663

Comments
SecurePoll and OpenSTV agree on final results.

Election setup

 * Candidates: 7
 * Seats: 6
 * Votes: 566

Actual
Output from SecurePoll: array(3) { ["elected"]=> array(6) { [0]=>   int(1) [1]=>   int(2) [2]=>   int(4) [3]=>   int(5) [4]=>   int(6) [5]=>   int(7) } ["eliminated"]=> array(1) { [0]=>   int(3) } ["rounds"]=> array(7) { [0]=>   array(8) { ["round"]=> int(1) ["surplus"]=> int(0) ["rankings"]=> array(7) { [1]=>       array(3) { ["votes"]=> int(0) ["earned"]=> int(102) ["total"]=> int(102) }       [2]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> int(0) ["earned"]=> int(101) ["total"]=> int(101) }       [3]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> int(0) ["earned"]=> int(72) ["total"]=> int(72) }       [4]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> int(0) ["earned"]=> int(73) ["total"]=> int(73) }       [5]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> int(0) ["earned"]=> int(72) ["total"]=> int(72) }       [6]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> int(0) ["earned"]=> int(73) ["total"]=> int(73) }       [7]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> int(0) ["earned"]=> int(73) ["total"]=> int(73) }     }      ["totalVotes"]=> int(566) ["keepFactors"]=> array(7) { [1]=>       int(1) [2]=>       int(1) [3]=>       int(1) [4]=>       int(1) [5]=>       int(1) [6]=>       int(1) [7]=>       int(1) }     ["quota"]=> int(81) ["elected"]=> array(0) { }     ["eliminated"]=> array(0) { }   }    [1]=>    array(8) { ["round"]=> int(2) ["elected"]=> array(2) { [0]=>       int(1) [1]=>       int(2) }     ["eliminated"]=> array(0) { }     ["surplus"]=> int(41) ["keepFactors"]=> array(7) { [1]=>       int(1) [2]=>       int(1) [3]=>       int(1) [4]=>       int(1) [5]=>       int(1) [6]=>       int(1) [7]=>       int(1) }     ["quota"]=> int(81) ["rankings"]=> array(7) { [1]=>       array(3) { ["votes"]=> int(102) ["earned"]=> int(0) ["total"]=> int(102) }       [2]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> int(101) ["earned"]=> int(0) ["total"]=> int(101) }       [3]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> int(72) ["earned"]=> int(0) ["total"]=> int(72) }       [4]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> int(73) ["earned"]=> int(0) ["total"]=> int(73) }       [5]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> int(72) ["earned"]=> int(0) ["total"]=> int(72) }       [6]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> int(73) ["earned"]=> int(0) ["total"]=> int(73) }       [7]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> int(73) ["earned"]=> int(0) ["total"]=> int(73) }     }      ["totalVotes"]=> int(566) }   [2]=>    array(8) { ["round"]=> int(3) ["elected"]=> array(0) { }     ["eliminated"]=> array(0) { }     ["surplus"]=> float(13.452824694234) ["keepFactors"]=> array(7) { [1]=>       float(0.79411764705882) [2]=>       float(0.8019801980198) [3]=>       int(1) [4]=>       int(1) [5]=>       int(1) [6]=>       int(1) [7]=>       int(1) }     ["quota"]=> int(81) ["rankings"]=> array(7) { [1]=>       array(3) { ["votes"]=> int(102) ["earned"]=> float(-15.967967384974) ["total"]=> float(86.032032615026) }       [2]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> int(101) ["earned"]=> float(-11.579207920792) ["total"]=> float(89.420792079208) }       [3]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> int(72) ["earned"]=> float(4.4231217239371) ["total"]=> float(76.423121723937) }       [4]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> int(73) ["earned"]=> float(5.9321490972626) ["total"]=> float(78.932149097263) }       [5]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> int(72) ["earned"]=> float(5.5960978450786) ["total"]=> float(77.596097845079) }       [6]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> int(73) ["earned"]=> float(4.8270238788584) ["total"]=> float(77.827023878858) }       [7]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> int(73) ["earned"]=> float(4.563191613279) ["total"]=> float(77.563191613279) }     }      ["totalVotes"]=> float(563.79440885265) }   [3]=>    array(8) { ["round"]=> int(4) ["elected"]=> array(0) { }     ["eliminated"]=> array(0) { }     ["surplus"]=> float(3.5277865434787) ["keepFactors"]=> array(7) { [1]=>       float(0.74766953025041) [2]=>       float(0.72645739910314) [3]=>       int(1) [4]=>       int(1) [5]=>       int(1) [6]=>       int(1) [7]=>       int(1) }     ["quota"]=> int(81) ["rankings"]=> array(7) { [1]=>       array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(86.032032615026) ["earned"]=> float(-3.2251175561715) ["total"]=> float(82.806915058855) }       [2]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(89.420792079208) ["earned"]=> float(-6.6999205945842) ["total"]=> float(82.720871484624) }       [3]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(76.423121723937) ["earned"]=> float(1.5894767057776) ["total"]=> float(78.012598429715) }       [4]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(78.932149097263) ["earned"]=> float(1.9344479538007) ["total"]=> float(80.866597051063) }       [5]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(77.596097845079) ["earned"]=> float(1.83231146844) ["total"]=> float(79.428409313519) }       [6]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(77.827023878858) ["earned"]=> float(1.7114476215026) ["total"]=> float(79.538471500361) }       [7]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(77.563191613279) ["earned"]=> float(1.5212667579291) ["total"]=> float(79.084458371208) }     }      ["totalVotes"]=> float(562.45832120934) }   [4]=>    array(8) { ["round"]=> int(5) ["elected"]=> array(1) { [2]=>       int(4) }     ["eliminated"]=> array(0) { }     ["surplus"]=> float(1.3106049527112) ["keepFactors"]=> array(7) { [1]=>       float(0.73135476556806) [2]=>       float(0.71134464943702) [3]=>       int(1) [4]=>       int(1) [5]=>       int(1) [6]=>       int(1) [7]=>       int(1) }     ["quota"]=> int(81) ["rankings"]=> array(7) { [1]=>       array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(82.806915058855) ["earned"]=> float(-1.453226051202) ["total"]=> float(81.353689007653) }       [2]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(82.720871484624) ["earned"]=> float(-1.1289950358799) ["total"]=> float(81.591876448744) }       [3]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(78.012598429715) ["earned"]=> float(0.39589661184799) ["total"]=> float(78.408495041563) }       [4]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(80.866597051063) ["earned"]=> float(0.49844244525074) ["total"]=> float(81.365039496314) }       [5]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(79.428409313519) ["earned"]=> float(0.45535741152858) ["total"]=> float(79.883766725047) }       [6]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(79.538471500361) ["earned"]=> float(0.42732412619649) ["total"]=> float(79.965795626558) }       [7]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(79.084458371208) ["earned"]=> float(0.39756990388039) ["total"]=> float(79.482028275088) }     }      ["totalVotes"]=> float(562.05069062097) }   [5]=>    array(8) { ["round"]=> int(6) ["elected"]=> array(0) { }     ["eliminated"]=> array(1) { [0]=>       int(3) }     ["surplus"]=> float(0.46862373961443) ["keepFactors"]=> array(7) { [1]=>       float(0.72817516616168) [2]=>       float(0.70618447708571) [3]=>       int(1) [4]=>       float(0.9955135584205) [5]=>       int(1) [6]=>       int(1) [7]=>       int(1) }     ["quota"]=> int(81) ["rankings"]=> array(7) { [1]=>       array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(81.353689007653) ["earned"]=> float(-0.173111795131) ["total"]=> float(81.180577212522) }       [2]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(81.591876448744) ["earned"]=> float(-0.43820501589461) ["total"]=> float(81.153671432849) }       [3]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(78.408495041563) ["earned"]=> float(0.17888387242287) ["total"]=> float(78.587378913986) }       [4]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(81.365039496314) ["earned"]=> float(-0.23066440207102) ["total"]=> float(81.134375094243) }       [5]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(79.883766725047) ["earned"]=> float(0.18933304855283) ["total"]=> float(80.0730997736) }       [6]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(79.965795626558) ["earned"]=> float(0.18920136162895) ["total"]=> float(80.154996988187) }       [7]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(79.482028275088) ["earned"]=> float(0.1761029912555) ["total"]=> float(79.658131266344) }     }      ["totalVotes"]=> float(561.94223068173) }   [6]=>    array(8) { ["round"]=> int(7) ["elected"]=> array(3) { [3]=>       int(5) [4]=>       int(6) [5]=>       int(7) }     ["eliminated"]=> array(0) { }     ["surplus"]=> float(75.901962461747) ["keepFactors"]=> array(7) { [1]=>       float(0.72655542106687) [2]=>       float(0.70484725624858) [3]=>       int(0) [4]=>       float(0.99386478466612) [5]=>       int(1) [6]=>       int(1) [7]=>       int(1) }     ["quota"]=> int(81) ["rankings"]=> array(7) { [1]=>       array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(81.180577212522) ["earned"]=> float(8.0356083540056) ["total"]=> float(89.216185566528) }       [2]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(81.153671432849) ["earned"]=> float(6.8746053209914) ["total"]=> float(88.028276753841) }       [3]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(78.587378913986) ["earned"]=> float(-78.587378913986) ["total"]=> float(0) }       [4]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(81.134375094243) ["earned"]=> float(19.389330238447) ["total"]=> float(100.52370533269) }       [5]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(80.0730997736) ["earned"]=> float(14.889948016427) ["total"]=> float(94.963047790027) }       [6]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(80.154996988187) ["earned"]=> float(13.110418664536) ["total"]=> float(93.265415652722) }       [7]=>        array(3) { ["votes"]=> float(79.658131266344) ["earned"]=> float(16.247200099595) ["total"]=> float(95.905331365939) }     }      ["totalVotes"]=> float(561.90196246175) } } }

Elected

 * 1) "1"
 * 2) "2"
 * 3) "4"
 * 4) "6"
 * 5) "5"
 * 6) "7"

Rounds table
(Results from 01:06, 29 July 2021)

Expected
Output from OpenSTV: Loading ballots from file 7_6_566_1185838663.blt. Ballot file contains 7 candidates and 566 ballots. No candidates have withdrawn. Ballot file contains 566 non-empty ballots.

Counting votes for ElectionTitle using Meek STV. 7 candidates running for 6 seats.

R|1            |2             |3             |4             |5 |--+--+--+--+-- |6             |7             |Exhausted     |Surplus       |Threshold

=
================================================================ 1|   102.000000|    101.000000|     72.000000|     73.000000|     72.000000  |     73.000000|     73.000000|      0.000000|     41.285714|     80.857143  |--  | Count of first choices. Candidates 1 and 2 have reached the threshold and | are elected.

=
================================================================ 2|    85.916273|     89.320255|     76.457006|     78.975549|     77.636402  |     77.863722|     77.597306|      2.233487|     14.160380|     80.538074  |--  | Count after transferring surplus votes. Keep factors of candidates who | have exceeded the threshold: 1, 0.792718 and 2, 0.800566.

=
================================================================ 3|    82.409869|     82.364946|     78.128809|     81.012156|     79.562124  |     79.663860|     79.200313|      3.657923|      4.783222|     80.334583  |--  | Count after transferring surplus votes. Keep factors of candidates who | have exceeded the threshold: 1, 0.743096 and 2, 0.721853. Candidate 4 has | reached the threshold and is elected.

=
================================================================ 4|    80.859000|     81.079419|     78.716280|     80.910733|     80.209923  |     80.291424|     79.792984|      4.140237|      2.077852|     80.265681  |--  | Count after transferring surplus votes. Keep factors of candidates who | have exceeded the threshold: 1, 0.724383; 2, 0.704059; and 4, 0.991637. | Candidate 6 has reached the threshold and is elected.

=
================================================================ 5|    80.537646|     80.525122|     79.004749|     80.466566|     80.512529  |     80.564631|     80.081220|      4.307537|      1.397589|     80.241781  |--  | Count after transferring surplus votes. Keep factors of candidates who | have exceeded the threshold: 1, 0.719068; 2, 0.696993; 4, 0.983732; and | 6, 0.999680. Candidate 5 has reached the threshold and is elected.

=
================================================================ 6|    80.417720|     80.426781|     79.220540|     80.408265|     80.420684  |     80.414630|     80.310382|      4.380998|      1.010740|     80.231287  |--  | Count after transferring surplus votes. Keep factors of candidates who | have exceeded the threshold: 1, 0.716427; 2, 0.694541; 4, 0.980984; 5, | 0.996638; and 6, 0.995674. Candidate 7 has reached the threshold and is | elected.

Winners are 1, 2, 4, 5, 6, and 7.

Files

 * blt: https://github.com/dominic998/SecurePoll-Test-Data/blob/main/test_data/7_6_566_1185838663.blt
 * php: https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/P16856

Environment

 * Where you tested: local docker using phpunit
 * Version of SecurePoll: commit 271145d5f3cae3b0a1b76d0f5dfeb609615d60b7 (patch 16 from https://gerrit.wikimedia.org/r/c/mediawiki/extensions/SecurePoll/+/704454/)