Global templates/Discuss

This is a page for 'collecting opinions about the Global templates proposal.

If you read the proposal and just agree to it, please sign below. If you disagree with something, write it here or on the proposal's talk page.

This is not a vote. The decision about this proposal will not be made just by counting how many people are for it or against it. It is not a part of Community Wishlist Survey or any other outreach or planning process. If this project is implemented, it will be a significant change in how the software on Wikimedia projects works, so it's important to see that there is wide community consensus before going forward with it.

Tell your wiki friends about this page and invite them to express their opinion, too. This proposal shouldn't be "owned" by just one person or a small group, but by the whole Wikimedia community.

I read the proposal and I think that it is a good idea
Please sign below if you think that this is an important problem to solve, and if you think that the proposed solution (tldr-link>Global templates/Proposed specification, short version|short version, full-link>Global templates/Proposed specification|long version) is good. If you think that the direction is generally good, but you have some minor corrections, please indicate this, too. You can write in any language.

[ support the proposal (visual editor) ]

[ support the proposal (source editor) ]

[ support the proposal (visual editor) ]

[ support the proposal (source editor) ]

I read the proposal. Let me explain why it is a bad idea
It's totally fine to disagree with this proposal. It should only be implemented if there is a wide consensus for it. Before signing below, please make sure that you've read at least tldr-link>Global templates/Proposed specification, short version|the short version of the solution proposal, and please explain what is the problem with it. You can write in any language.

[ oppose the proposal (visual editor) ]

[ oppose the proposal (source editor) ]

[</> oppose the proposal (visual editor) ]

[<tvar|url></> oppose the proposal (source editor) ]