Reading/Web/Advanced mobile contributions/Navigation prototype feedback

Over the past couple of weeks we have been working on iterating our mobile navigation design ideas based on the feedback we received from editors during Wikimania and afterwards. Below is the updated prototype for our navigation. We are interested in your thoughts on the layout of the navigation, as well as on the expanded set of links available. Any and all comments are appreciated!

Instructions

 * 1) Please pull up the prototype on a mobile device: https://mobile-contributions.firebaseapp.com/nav4.html (this site will soon be replaced by a WMF hosted site)
 * 2) Please create a new section below with your username as a heading (if you are logged out, the section heading can just be "anonymous").
 * 3) Copy the feedback form below and paste it into the new section you created
 * 4) Fill in your feedback/answers in the table

If you do not feel comfortable leaving feedback here and would prefer to do so anonymously, feel free to email Olga Vasileva at olga@wikimedia.org. She will forward your feedback to the rest of the team. Also, keep in mind that since this is a prototype most of the links don’t actually work, and there might be other bugs or quirks that you’ll come across.

NRay (WMF)

 * 1) Please pull up the prototype on a mobile device: https://mobile-contributions.firebaseapp.com/nav4.html (this site will soon be replaced by a WMF hosted site)
 * 2) What device and browser are you using?
 * 3) feedback: Pixel with Chrome
 * 4) Take a minute or two to orient yourself, click around, get a lay of the land.
 * 5) What are some of your initial impressions (do you find anything confusing? Convenient? Particularly notable?)
 * 6) feedback: Clean and simple design. Looks good! I REALLY like the article sticky nav when you scroll. Articles can get really long so that is very convenient if I spot an edit I want to make as I read.
 * 7) Is anything particularly hard to find?
 * 8) feedback: Profile button & notifications buttons are in a common location, hamburger menu contains sensible general items, article menu contains sensible items that pertain to article.
 * 9) Is anything missing?
 * 10) feedback: Not a frequent editor but noticed view source button that is on desktop is not present on prototype
 * 11) Try navigating to the following places, adding any feedback you have.
 * 12) An article’s talk page
 * 13) feedback: Article / Talk buttons were not immediately clear that they were buttons. Article and Talk buttons might be better represented as tabs?
 * 14) The main search
 * 15) feedback: Search box feels small and a bit crowded. Would like it to expand when clicked and be bigger
 * 16) Your own talk page
 * 17) feedback: Initially confused that this was another button and not referring to article's talk page but then found it easily. Would like to see "My talk page" as label for this button instead of "Your talk page"
 * 18) The wikidata item for a page
 * 19) feedback: Found easily
 * 20) Community portal
 * 21) feedback: Initially wasn't sure if this would belong in profile menu or hamburger menu but makes sense this would be hamburger menu since it is more general
 * 22) Your sandbox
 * 23) feedback: Found easily
 * 24) Alerts
 * 25) feedback: Found easily
 * 26) Final thoughts? Anything goes…
 * 27) Feedback: Nice work!