Extension talk:Graph/Interactive Graph Tutorial

Great tutorial. One issue, that is comments in Vega. On the page you included c style "// ..." comments. The Vega editor doesn't accept comments in the JSON specification. However, extension graph does accepts comments. Wiki style comments are accepted by mediawiki, including within graphs. However those wiki style comments are not accepted in the Vega editor. Somehow c style "// ..." comments are accepted within graphs by extension:graph in mediawiki, they are treated as comment, that is white space, that is ignored. Please note that outside graphs "// ..." is normally displayed and not treated as comment. Vega and JSON doesn't like comments, except for adding fields ("description": "vega acceptable comment style"). What I expect in a tutorial on graphs is source material that works both in the Wikimedia farm as in the Vega editor. Ideally your tutorial examples are added upstream. However that is sending users to another site for sandboxing. They could also experiment with examples in a sandbox space on this wiki. Ad Huikeshoven (talk) 10:17, 31 December 2015 (UTC)

Awesome geo examples
The world map is an awesome geo example. The boundaries are specified in a json source. How to create such a geojson or topojson file? For example, on commons is an SVG map of Dutch municipalities. Shown are only the boundaries. The sources contains the names (and numbers) of the individual municipalities. Where can I find a tool to convert such a SVG specification of the boundaries to a json specification that can be rendered with extension:graph? Ad Huikeshoven (talk) 13:50, 31 December 2015 (UTC)
 * Hi Yurik. On the site http://opendata.rug.nl/datasets/0667f758c7df48e1b2053593a67d1c30_0 I found the geojson specification of Dutch Municipality boundaries: http://opendata.rug.nl/datasets/0667f758c7df48e1b2053593a67d1c30_0.geojson. I have found node.js and npm and with the explanation on https://github.com/mbostock/topojson/wiki/Command-Line-Reference I could do topojson -o output.json -p -- input.json to get Sjabloon:Graph:Gemeentegrenzen/topojson as the map data for a template graph wikipedia:nl:Sjabloon:Graph:Gemeentegrenzen, which somehow fails to show something. I used http://www.mapshaper.org/ to check if the topojson can show something, and in fact it does. So something is wrong with the graph specification and/or topojson data, which I haven't figured out yet. Ad Huikeshoven (talk) 14:41, 2 January 2016 (UTC)
 * Ad Huikeshoven, there are online tools like this (better) or this, that convert geojson to topojson.  The top element in topojson needs to be specified, e.g.         - that feature element might be different, probably depending on the converter. --Yurik (talk) 15:15, 2 January 2016 (UTC)
 * As I wrote I used an offline converter. I have used the online tool mapshaper to view my topojson file, and it looks good. I copied the top element in topojson from https://www.mediawiki.org//w/index.php?title=Extension:Graph/data/us-10m-json&action=raw . Ok, have a look at User:Ad_Huikeshoven/gemeenten - those are the Dutch municipalities. Yurik eventually it was a matter of scaling, which I don't understand yet. Ad Huikeshoven (talk) 17:40, 2 January 2016 (UTC)
 * Awesome! Sorry couldn't answer earlier - i was in the air. I am not sure myself how the centering and scaling in vega work, but i'm sure we can figure them out eventually :D  I will post about it separately. --Yurik (talk) 21:19, 2 January 2016 (UTC)
 * Thanks for all the help. I've looked at your example and created a map with individually colored Dutch municipalities. The specification embeds the secondary data to color the individual municipalities. I discovered that the secondary dataset has to be defined in the   field prior to the primary dataset, otherwise it won't work. On mouseover (hover) the municipalities turn pink. This will only show in mode interactive, not in normal mode, or in normal mode while in preview. Nonetheless, I now have map of Dutch municipalities working in Graph which can be parametrized and templatized to become useful on a project. Ad Huikeshoven (talk) 22:30, 3 January 2016 (UTC)