User talk:AalekhN/GSoC proposal 2014

Asirra
Hi, isn't this feature basically the same as what Asirra is doing with cats and dogs? See Extension:Asirra, and a real example running in MediaWiki here.--Qgil (talk) 23:06, 6 March 2014 (UTC)

--Hi, What i mentioned in this proposal is different from Asirra,in two ways:
 * --I proposed use of data mining to extract images from the Wiki commons database through its API...Asirra on the other hand is more about image recognition ,moreover use of image recognition is not preferred as discussed in here : https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Talk:CAPTCHA#lqt_thread_id_39998
 * --Asirra is proprietary and can't be self-hosted....Wiki Commons on the other hand is a part of Wikimedia as mentoined in a reply  here : https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Talk:CAPTCHA#lqt_thread_id_40174 --AalekhN(talk)

ConfirmEdit / node
Two Questions: CSteipp (talk) 01:13, 7 March 2014 (UTC)
 * Are you proposing to extend or integrate with the existing ConfirmEdit extension, or would this be a competing extension?
 * You mentioned node.js as a part of your development environment-- are you planning to do part of this in javascript instead of PHP? Having the captchas require other languages besides php has been an issue with fancy captcha (generation is in python), and I would caution against it unless there is a really compelling reason for it.

--Hi ,I plan to make it as an integration to ConfirmEdit extension....if required we can also make it as an separate extenstion.
 * -Mention of node server was more of a typing mistake and has been corrected by now ......since this proposal is more about data mining I don't think there is a need to use other languages such as python or node as discussed in a comment here: https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Talk:CAPTCHA#lqt_thread_id_39998 AalekhN (talk)


 * Thanks. Please just integrate with ConfirmEdit-- a separate extension will make things more difficult in the future, which is why I was concerned about it. It sounds like you're on a good track. Good luck.


 * Also, when you consider your proposal complete and you've settled on a specific idea, please move it to the appropriate title as a subpage of CAPTCHA (per instructions). --Nemo 13:08, 8 March 2014 (UTC)

Watch the complexity
Just reading the captcha question gave me a headache... I'm not a designer so I'm unable to comment on specific ideas; but, again, you'll need some scientific research/usability testing to support whatever approach you choose. --Nemo 17:31, 13 March 2014 (UTC)