Project:Pywikibot/Migrating to bugzilla

Hello,

I'm Amir (User:Ladsgroup) and I suggested to PWB people in pywikipedia-l to migrate from sourceforge (which currently is PWB bug tracker now) to Bugzilla. They're agreed So I request here to migrate because of these reasons:


 * 1) In the sourceforge, people can report bugs via OpenID. So you don't need to register and every week we receive spam/non-sense reports that won't happen If we use bugzilla (or rarely happens)
 * 2) This become a centralized bug tracker. Some of PWB devs are also mediawiki devs so they have to work on bugzilla and sourceforge separately to track bugs but in this way, all of related bugs for them, will show in a page
 * People don't know sourceforge (So it's hard for them to report If they see any bugs) but they know bugzilla

Best, Ladsgroup (talk) 10:32, 27 May 2013 (UTC)

Discussion
I disagree with (1): it's an advantage that people can easily submit bugs, not a disadvantage. The spam bugs are actually not submitted using OpenID, but rather just by anonymous users. I also think (3) is nonsense - the typical user doesn't know bugzilla either, and will just click a link and write down some things there. (2) is somewhat an advantage, but 'show all relevant bugs' is nonsense, because that is neigh-impossible in bugzilla.

During the hackathon, I discussed this (among others) with André Klapper. The basic idea is to first move to gerrit. Afterwards, we can check what the best bug tracker option is. Valhallasw (talk) 11:23, 27 May 2013 (UTC)


 * I think we must distinguish between ordinary people and bot operators. bot operators are usually experienced wikipedians (I am emphasizing on this part) and reporting a bug in bugzilla is more easier than using OpenID and submitting a bug in sourceforge for these people (Please see people who recently submitted bugs, All of them has account in bugzilla and they report mediawiki bugs too). about (2) I meant if you vote or add your e-mail to cc you can see all of your bugs in "My bugs" or if you're dev of both mediawiki and PWB, you can see bugs assigned to you in "Assigned to me" (all of them in one place) in sidebar Ladsgroup (talk) 09:40, 28 May 2013 (UTC)


 * Personally I never liked sourceforge's tracker very much, so I would love to move to bugzilla. I think Valhallasw brings up a good point though, lets migrate to gerrit first and once that's all settled down we should then discuss bug tracking. Legoktm (talk) 18:37, 30 May 2013 (UTC)


 * I agree that we should move to Bugzilla after we've migrated to Gerrit.  Hazard-SJ  ±   23:44, 30 May 2013 (UTC)

Support

 * Per above Ladsgroup (talk) 10:32, 27 May 2013 (UTC)

valhallasw's brain farts
Valhallasw (talk) 20:36, 10 June 2013 (UTC)
 * who do we need to make a new project on bugzilla? André Klapper, probably?
 * what do we want as name? (let the bikeshedding begin)
 * what components do we want? and how do these correspond to items at sf.net?
 * how can we make sure bugs link to eachother? i.e. a link from BZ to sf.net and from sf.net to BZ?
 * how can we get an export from sf.net? I know there *should* be a button, but I can't find it. If you need any sf.net permissions for this, let me know.
 * can we allow anonymous/openid submitted bugs? I think there has been discussion about this on wikitech-l, so it might be good to bump that.