Talk:Mobile design/Ribbon navigation

From the side?
I wonder if the "ribbon" should slide out horizontally. Since it holds functionality related to the page itself I find the connection to the search bar really odd. Knocked this up to make it clear what I mean:

Behaviour
Bear in mind that in the current behaviour on clicking the 'ribbon arrow' the search box will push the ribbon down and the finger will then be over the search box. There might be issues with this as the user then might accidently trigger a search with their finger in that same position. If the arrow comes from the right of the screen then I think it is acceptable to leave it in the same position leaving a gap for the search box to slot into.

Also bear in mind that sticky elements and animation from my experience do not mix to the point that certain browsers should not use slide down animations - this might be jarring to a user.

Table of contents icon
The icon being used to mean "table of contents" is extremely unclear. (I originally assumed that it was just going to be another menu for things that wouldn't fit in the expanding left-side navigation bar, resulting in much confusion as to where which buttons would be. I only figured it out after seeing the same icon in the current beta leading to a table of contents.) Using an icon virtually indistinguishable from standard "menu" icons is probably inadvisable. Anyway, is there any reason for having a table of contents in the first place? The sections are collapsed, so the ToC wouldn't actually be any smaller than the section headers themselves. I don't see how it could be at all useful. --Yair rand (talk) 21:49, 23 September 2012 (UTC)
 * Eliminating the TOC is actually a discussion that is being had. I used the icons that were pre-existing; I'm not happy with many of them.  There should have been a note indicating that what goes in the Ribbon is still being discussed and is really out of scope for the specific design.--Jorm (WMF) (talk) 21:59, 23 September 2012 (UTC)