Extension:MoodBar/Feedback

It seems we have two different tools for doing feedback that are starting to be used in various places. Should we be combining our efforts?

Feedback.js


A simple feedback system which appends the user's comment to a wiki page. In use on UploadWizard and VisualEditor. Siebrand wants to use it for some upcoming projects like Narayam.

Pros:
 * Easy to use
 * Easy to configure
 * Can have multiple feedback links on a page, all targeting different feedback pages.
 * Is wiki-centric, all the usual tools work here.

Cons:
 * Hard to manage feedback, can grow very long
 * Note auto-archiving possibilities via bots, e.g. User:MiszaBot is actively archiving UW feedback and theoretically visual editor feedback
 * Not easy to mark feedback as being dealt with - perhaps by adding to a bug
 * Cf. Template:Tracked
 * Not easy to get stats
 * Not easy to respond to user who posted feedback

Extension:Moodbar


System for getting affective feedback, potentially with commentary, about an entire site. Smile/Frown/Huh? plus comments goes into its own database

Pros:
 * Really easy to use
 * Possible to get stats

Cons:
 * Not as configurable ... yet
 * Focused on one-on-one interaction (helping new users). User talk pages are probably not the best place to post feedback responses.

Planned future features:
 * Tagging responses
 * "Universal" ability to make moodbars about certain things
 * Queueing feedback, to be distributed among volunteers, to respond to the user