Thread:Talk:Flow/Auto-archiving/reply (33)

I'm not dead set against it but I admit I'm very very skeptical about it to the point I will first believe it when I see it and when I see it works.

Have you stated somewhere how you will prevent the problems I mentioned? I'm sure you improved upon LiquidThreads (and I only used it as a rough example to get an idea of what I'm talking about), but how will you solve the fundamental problem of the "feeds" design? How will you make sure people know what they are discussing? How will you prevent endless discussion without real result (as the "flow" might produce)? Do you think people come back to a talk page and solve all the open issues on this talk page as they do currently, when the talk page is nothing more than a feed of multiple threads "flowing" around? Maybe my view is too narrow to see how this should work, but I'd be happy if you tried to enlighten me.

Although I admit this might be unpleasant questions, I think those are valid concerns and you'd be better off to take them into consideration.