Comparison of Dynamic Pagelist x Semantic Mediawiki

From MediaWiki.org
Jump to: navigation, search

"Dynamic Pagelist" and "Semantic Mediawiki" two excellent extensions for Mediawiki. Both produce lists of articles and lots more. They are similar but no substitute for each other. They both are very complex and so it is not easy to make a choice. This page will compare them.

Dynamic Pagelist Semantic Mediawiki
Link to Extension Link Link
Homepage [1] [2]
License GPLv2
Version-History 1.8.9 (2009-10-01) 1.5.2 (2010-08-30)
Release status stable stable
development active active
advantage easier to learn more flexible
forms no yes, Semantic Forms
mass deletion yes no
Export yes yes
mainfeatures manage structured data:
  • assign key-value pairs to pages,
  • view pages based on values,
  • generate dynamic views/page lists ("inline queries")
more features
Extensions no yes
installed on Wikipedia no no
Demoinstallation of the extension yes [3] (copy of wikipedia) Sandbox site (public playground), MW-based web portal (advanced application, read-only)
Documentation [4] [5]
Lists of sites using this extension [6] [7], [8]
Sample reports yes [9]
Support mailing lists [10]
Commercial support yes, various providers